What More Politics – Why Trump is Good for the Country

Disclaimer

This is mostly an education blog, but education is a subversive activity,

Book Cover

I really should read this book one day

so I’m stuck talking politics a lot lately. There is much injustice in the world and for me the big injustice is the lack of resources we give to education. Both in the underserved school district where I work and in general. While I would love it if the military had to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber,

text quote

Maybe Robert Fulgram or maybe just a random PTA mom

I’ll be satisfied if I worked in a school where I didn’t have the nagging worry of asbestos in the floor tiles. With all that said here is my political piece for the day.

Why Trump is good for the country.

If Clinton had won, we would be stuck in another 4 years of obstructionism, with fake concerns about how there might or might not be voter fraud which lead to disenfranchisement. The slow grind towards civil rights would wear down even the most ardent supporters. And in the end little or nothing would actually change. With Clinton’s loss however, the liberal voters have sent a clear message. “We are sick and tired of Republican lite candidates.”

Of course the Washington Democrats aren’t listening. It will be a long four years.

Don’t get me wrong. I love Mrs. Clinton. I think she is one of the smartest people on the planet. I think she cares deeply for the vulnerable. I think she would have been a president we could all be proud of. But in the end she was working within the system. And for some reason we want the system to be torn down.

Maybe it is because for eight years the GOP has obstructed progress and they only grew in power,. Maybe it is because we finally realize that there is no such thing as a benevolent dictator (even if it comes in the form of a democratically elected congress). Maybe, it is because promises have been made and none of them kept. It doesn’t matter, what is done is done and we are left to pick up the pieces.

Facing prospects such as an EPA that may not exist in four years, an energy policy that wants to go backwards, and a school system that may be sold to the highest bidder (think vulture capitalists breaking up a large company). One might be tempted to think progressives have lost. You would be wrong.

Instead of dragging an unwilling population, kicking and screaming, into modern society we get to define what a modern society is and is not willing to accept. We will not drag others we will simply go there and stand our ground.

The alt-right can mass thousands of trolls online to fight, smear, put down, and even dox good people. The left can motivate millions of people to actually stand up and take action. And what do those actions say:

We are setting the agenda for our future.

All people are created equal – this basic tenant about America has a capital ALL. Not just white property holders, not just men, not just anything. ALL and they can vote, hold jobs, buy cake, etc…

Privacy is important – Governments and corporations cannot have access to us or our metadata without asking first. The net is neutral, Comcast and ATT do not get to decide to charge more for Netflix.

Truth – There is a difference between news and propaganda and we will need to define that line.

Social Welfare – Do we really care about our children and elders? How much are we willing to actually do for them? How much will that cost?

The American Dream – Is it to become rich or is it to become free? Money is not God – The definition of success is not measured in dollars. Who is allowed to dream that dream?

This and more, we will spend the next fours years leading America towards greatness. Or we might all burn in a nuclear annihilation. Either way, it’s a step up from the current administration policies.

 

 

Protesting is Protected by the Constitution

I spent a bit of time watching a protest march in Los Angeles Saturday. It wasn’t violent, they weren’t demanding a change in the election results (but I’m sure many would be pleased if the Electoral College refused to vote for Trump based on his lack of qualifications for the job), they weren’t really demanding anything specific, they were just venting their anger.

I don’t really have many Republican friends (funny because I was a Republican precinct committeeman for 4 years), but the few I have share memes and don’t really explain in a coherent way what they want. She’s a crook and he isn’t, which is just ludicrous to me. (Yes, I listened to every argument and as close as I could come is she let the ends justify the means. A highway to hell certainly, but transparency is something specific to demand and measure.).

I get that many Americans are angry, I’m angry, but most people also claimed to be a friend of the LGBTQ community, non-violent, and non-racist. So I just don’t get how so many voted for a man who advocated violence, racism, and anti-gay policies. Yeah, I saw the video of his speech where he said he was a friend to the LGBTQ community “believe me” and people of color weren’t getting any help from the democrats so what have you got to lose, but actions speak louder than words. (SNL taught me not to be surprised at the level of racism in this country).

I guess I don’t get why people turned to the Republican party at all. Ok the Democratic party hasn’t actually followed through on their promises, but at least they had workable promises. All those old good paying jobs with low entry barriers, they aren’t coming back. We can start a trade war with China and Mexico, but those jobs still aren’t coming back. At best we will build robots to bring those jobs back. (I don’t think robot designer is a job for a high school diploma). Steel, coal, those jobs are on a downward trend and nothing we do will ever change that, time to retool and find something new. (The real whiners aren’t millennials looking for a safe space, they are laid off workers looking for a job as easy and high paying as the one they used to have. Your boss is a business person he won’t pay more until you prove you are worth more).

That isn’t to say we shouldn’t have jobs that pay well, we should (fight for $15 and all). The problem is most of those jobs wont be in manufacturing. When you complain about a high paying manufacturing job being sent to non-union Mexico on the one hand and then tell us that a McDonald’s employee doesn’t deserve $15 an hour, you are contradicting yourself. I guarantee you the CEO of General Motors didn’t think it was worth paying a union employee $60,000 a year to tighten a bolt over and over everyday.

Do you want America to be great again? Join a union (don’t complain about the dues), work for equality in treatment and wages. Demand that every full-time job require full-time pay. Demand universal healthcare. Demand equality for all. Stop whining about the past and build the future.

 

Coming Together

I have spent 8 years watching Republicans refuse to accept defeat. I’ve seen them stop the entire federal government twice. I’ve seen them refuse to accept nominations for the judicial branch of government, they didn’t argue against them, they just up and ignored their duty.

I’ve watched as they attacked and attempted to humiliate their opponents just for the sake of attack and vilification. and I have to say I’m pretty tired of it. I’ve been tired of it for a long time. It’s why I stopped being a Republican.

I’m all for smaller more efficient government, but there should be a government.
I’m all for encouraging business to start and grow, but I’m not willing to do it for them.
I’m all for the rights as defined in the constitution, but I also believe your right to swing a fist ends at my face.

I’m also for “We the People”, I believe everyone is equal. I believe in giving a hand up because I’ve seen the world crush good hard-working people without a second thought.

So now after eight years of obstruction and attack the anti-establishment insider finally wins. Not really a win because a majority of the people want the other candidate, but an electoral college win.

I know what is coming. We won, we have a mandate, you have to listen to us. Well no, you didn’t listen to me I don’t have to listen to you.but I won’t play that game. I won’t advocate the intentional hurt of America just for political gain.

I will however throw the ball into your lap. You think you have won, then act like a winner. reach out to me.

Your ideas are better? Stop trying to ram them down my throat and convince me. And be real about it. I’ve seen your ideals in action before, our country went from a budget surplus and peace to two wars and the Great Recession. So your conviction had better be able to explain how it will be different this time.

You almost destroyed the country last time and I’m afraid you will finish the job this time.

Dear White People

Yes I did watch the movie. Good, but not great in my opinion.

I know I’m white so this may seem a bit strange, but I’m going to try to explain people of color. I’m not the expert, but I hope that my being white helps people to understand.

I’m not claiming I am or ever have been a victim, or profiled, or anything like that. I don’t even have a lot of friends who are people of color, some co-workers, and Facebook friends, but not people I hang out with. Of course being an introvert I don’t really hang out with anyone, but my own kids.

What I do have is a desire to listen and learn. I listen as my friends speak at work, I read, a lot, Facebook posts, articles, books, etc…. I don’t blame, I don’t make excuses. So this is what I see.

Yes, racism is alive and well in America, thanks for asking. I’m a little racist. It’s true, I took that Harvard test and was disappointed in my results. But not really surprised. I grew up in a white middle class suburb and for the most part I have lived in one my entire life.

I also travel a lot, or at least I did when I was younger. I stayed up all night with strangers from foreign countries. I once even had coffee with 5 guys and we had to translate everything said not once but twice because 3 guys spoke Czech, 1 spoke only German, and I spoke only English.  I learned my white middle class American culture was not the only one, not the best, and not always the default.

Don’t get me wrong. I like my culture. I’m proud of it. It is just important for me to realize that when we talk about American culture I am the default. I am the guy people assume we are talking about in movies, newspapers, nightly news, on the Internet. When anyone speaks of Americans without any specification, they are talking about a guy like me. Though perhaps I am aged out of the default population now.

Being the default you might assume that I would get offended when people of color tell me there is systematic racism in America. Or basically I’m the problem. Except that while I am the typical American, I know I am not America. Not all black people are thugs, not all cops are murderers, not all white people are racist. I may be the average white, middle class, Christian American, but I am also an individual.

My responsibility, when someone of color says there is systematic racism, is to accept that fact. Sure if some fictional black guy, says the world is against me because I’m black, that doesn’t mean anything. When he says, “my dad had the talk with me about looking non-threatening when pulled over by the police.” I have to realize that his life is different than mine. I cannot discount his words because my experiences are different.

I think that is the hurdle most people seem to trip on. Their experiences are different. When I get pulled over I pull out my license and insurance then hold them in my hands on top of my steering wheel. In plain view. Three out of the last four times I was pulled over I received a warning. The timeline for this was a span of over 12 years. Not 52 times in just a few years. My responsibility is to accept that life and my experience are different. I will have to judge others by their words and experiences not my own.

My responsibility is to accept the fact that I sometimes have an unconscious bias and to stop denying it, especially when someone points it out. I need to take a critical look at myself and my actions and probably make some changes.

My responsibility is to stop holding my tongue when friends say or do something with bias. Not just racist memes, but unconscious attitudes and behaviors.

My responsibility is to find that area of my life where I can support change and do it. Real actions, not just write a congressman or share a #blacklivesmatter meme. As a teachers I give my students of color a voice in my room. I try to listen and implement their ideas while at the same time asking them to think critically and be accountable for following up. This is high standards, not that crap with tests.

My responsibility is to grow as a person.

My responsibility is to allow everyone their equality, and not complain that it is infringing on mine, because it isn’t.

My responsibility is to support not fight.

Education and Politics

I usually like to stick to education on this blog, but I thought I’d take a little foray into politics. This 2016 election year has been interesting to say the least. I’m generally a Democrat but I have spent a lot of time with Republicans and I believe I understand the lure of the Republican platform. Who would not be excited about lower taxes, a smaller more efficient government, and people with values?

There are of course differences between Republicans and Democrats. Republicans want government to do as little as possible and private enterprise to do as much as possible. This whole social conservative movement that has erupted over the last 20 or 30 years is not part of the original Republican Party. It’s something that I think some politicians have used energize the base, but is not really part of the real conservatism.

Democrats on the other hand see as government as a tool of the people. Democrats don’t necessarily see government is evil, but they know that government can do evil. What they do want government to do, what they believe government does best, are those things that individuals can’t necessarily do. The government should protect people from the powerful, protect people from being exploited, force the powerful to do what’s right, fund and share large project that help the country as a whole, but aren’t necessarily direct money makers

The differences are pretty basic as far as I can see. Republicans see a problem and they try to shine a light on it and create incentives for the free market or private enterprise to fix the problem. Democrats see a problem and they want the best solution to be found and implemented.

Now if the problem is building an infrastructure, such as roads, or water systems, or even delivery of education, I think the government is the right entity to provide that solution. These are huge projects that benefit everyone, even those people who don’t use them on a regular basis (this in my mind makes me a Democrat). So yes, our collective will, the government, should be the person who leads the development and financing of these projects. On the other hand the national government shouldn’t be making small detailed decisions like where should the stop sign go, or how much fluoride should I put in the water, or exactly what should be taught during March of the school year in a local elementary school. These decisions are best left to the local people.

Take for example the Department of Education. It was created by the Carter Administration. only a Democrat would think of elevating the Department of Education to a cabinet level position. On the other hand only a Republican would think of pushing the limits of those powers. In 2000 Bush decided to use the Department of Education to help underprivileged schools. It is no surprise that for many years students in underprivileged neighborhoods had schools that are failing; they often have buildings that are falling down, they have less equipment, many have less effective teachers, and students generally don’t do as well or learn as much as their more privileged peers.

With the Republican mindset of a government that doesn’t do things, but encourages businesses or people to do things it makes sense to Start No Child Left Behind. If you start with just the general idea of schools are bad, let’s tell people and require the people make them better that doesn’t sound like a bad thing does it? And really it isn’t, it’s not bad to shine light on the truth. And the truth is that schools and students in underprivileged neighborhoods get the short end of the shaft.

The problem is the execution of the policy. Politicians are more often than not lawyers, not educators, they don’t understand how education works. Like most people they went through school where the teacher taught, they took the test, if they passed the test then they must have learned something. So NCLB is set up that way, give kids a test and if they pass they learned if they fail they must not have learned. This leads to the inevitable conclusion that the teachers didn’t teach and the schools aren’t working.

After Bush came Obama and Democrats. Democrats see government as needing to fix what is wrong. Since Republicans were so nice to shine a light on the problem Democrats decided to institute a fix.

The Obama administration followed No Child Left Behind with Race To The Top. Race To The Top took the idea that these schools were failing and we need to institute researched based policies to fix them. This sounds good to me except for the part where research says basically anything you want it to say and so politicians / lawyers devised the solutions that would somehow fix education.

There are a lot of problems with schools in our poorest neighborhoods. the best teachers often leave as soon as they can, resources are woefully inadequate, buildings are falling down, often community support is lacking, and the culture can be counterproductive (If you don’t see education as a ticket to a better life you don’t value education). Unfortunately not every school faces the exact same set of problems so a solution has to be created for each school and each district separately. There can’t be one set of instructions for everybody. And the policies that were picked sounded good, but rarely worked.

The real fix for education is a simple compromise between the Republican and Democratic approaches to the problem. There needs to be a light shined on the issues facing schools, but it has to shine on all of these issues, lack of support, lack of money, lack of community, all of that stuff has to be brought to light. We can’t depend on the goodwill of businesses or nonprofits or community volunteers to fix these problems, we have to as a people, as a government entity, decide that we value education and provide the necessary support. Those supports include wraparound services, building the support structure necessary to make education possible.

Then we need to step back and let local districts decide what that means. If this sounds like education in the 1990s before Bush instituted No Child Left Behind, then you’re half right. It is except before No Child Left Behind there was no spot light being shined on these districts. Have you ever been to a school board meeting? Nobody shows up. The school board is there, the principles are there, the superintendent is there, and usually the union president is there. The only time the public shows up to a school board meeting is when somebody is winning an award, or somebody’s in trouble.

Obviously locally elected school boards are not really being monitored. So some sort of monitoring or justification for implementing policies and follow up on whether they’re actually working or not is necessary. And it might actually be good or better if it’s being monitored by somebody higher up, the state or the national level. It could provide more stability, often schools will go in one direction while a superintendent is running the school district and then that person moves on, somebody new is hired and the direction changes. Schools and education don’t work when you change direction every 2 or 3 years.

Schools and the people in our poorest neighborhoods need more than just edicts from a government power. They need the time and support to develop and implement their own solutions to their own problems. The Republican solution which seems to be telling people to doing stuff wrong and either fix it or get in trouble doesn’t work. The Democratic solution of implementing a fix designed in the White House or on Capitol Hill will not work. Each solution needs to be developed and implemented in each neighborhood, custom solutions for each individual problem. The government needs to hire good people and let them do what they are good at doing.

Keeping Your Job

About a year ago a senator from the great state of Illinois had a massive stroke. He almost died. Recently that senator returned to work amid cheering crowds of his fellow senators and congressmen, and quite a few cameras.


Never Give Up

I’m glad my senator is healthy enough and back to work. I wouldn’t have wanted him to have been replaced with someone appointed by the Republican Party. We, the voters, did hire him and it seems we were happy to wait for him to return.

During the year he was gone he took all the time he needed to recover. He rehabbed, and according to most doctors he seems to have excelled in his recovery, coming back faster and more completely than expected.

However, in the last year he did not go to work, he voted on no bills, he participated in no public discussions, he made very few appearances.

I’m not disappointed in that, actually I think it was the right thing to do. The real question is, “Would this have been the same for any other employee?”

Recently, I was asked to donate some of my sick time at work to another person. S/he would have run out of sick days and would not have been paid. S/he then would have had to make a choice; quit treatment and go back to work (if that were possible) or quit work and fall on the mercy of public aid.

Medical bills are a major cause of bankruptcy in this country. Major illness is not covered. Well the hospital bills are covered (usually only 80% after deductible). But if you can’t go to work eventually your boss can’t keep paying you, especially if s/he has to hire someone else to do your job. Long term social security disability will kick in after a year, but what do you do after your sick days and vacation days run out? For most people that means a maximum of less than a month.

Enhanced by Zemanta